What are the main differences and when should you choose one over another?
Aren’t they all just managed container services?
Yeah, they’re all “managed”, but to differing degrees.
GKE = K8s platform where GCP take care of the underlying infra and control plane. So it’s a “Managed” service in the sense that someone else (namely Google) manages the VMs and the initial control plane setup.
GKE Autopilot = K8s platform where the folks at Google take care of the underlying infra AND the node configuration & management AND the monitoring & logging.
Cloud Run = Fully Managed container Platform-as-a-Service (or serverless container platform, if you’re a hipster), which basically means you can’t touch anything and it’s all built-in and managed for you by the google GCP bots – this includes auto-scaling (obvs), health checks, and monitoring & logging.
Is that the only difference between them?
Nope, but it’s the most fundamental one. Because you’re getting different levels of “management” from each offering, you’re also getting different features and benefits. For example, with autopilot, the management of the nodes is done by Google, so to a consumer the nodes are locked down. That’s arguably a good thing. It also means that Google take care of all the node maintenance and security.
And I’m guessing the billing is different too?
Correct. The billing is different too.
For autopilot, you don’t get charged for unused pods or for any unallocated space. So that’s nice.
Check out the pricing calculator for an estimate: https://cloud.google.com/products/calculator
And the other main differences?
- Cloud Run is a doddle to work with compared to GKE. Hardly any learning curve worth mentioning. However, it does have some limitations. For example the fully managed Cloud Run solution doesn’t support Kafka events/messages, so you’d need to move to pub/sub!
- You also can’t increase the limits on Memory and CPU (obviously – it’s a fully managed platform, duh)
- If you’re one of those posh people who have Security Command Centre Premium tier, the bad news is Container Threat Detection doesn’t work with autopilot or cloud run https://cloud.google.com/security-command-center/docs/concepts-container-threat-detection-overview
- Binary Authorization https://cloud.google.com/binary-authorization/docs/overview is available for Cloud Run and GKE but NOT autopilot, so there’s that (why??).
- Other security features such as Google Groups for RBAC, App layer secrets encryption and customer-managed encryption are available in Autopilot – you just need to enable them (in the Advanced options) when you’re creating a cluster:
If you’d like an exhaustive side-by-side comparison of all features of GKE and Autopilot (not just the main differences) then this is the place to go: https://cloud.google.com/kubernetes-engine/docs/concepts/autopilot-overview#comparison
Which one should you use?
And if that doesn’t fit your requirements then use autopilot.
And if that doesn’t fit your requirements then use GKE.
When should I use Cloud Run?
People say Cloud Run is ideally suited to startups, which I agree with (ease of setup, faster time to market, blah blah blah). But I don’t think this makes it unsuitable for any other type of organisation. I work with large financial services and I could see a massive benefit of using Cloud Run because it’s so easy to get up-and-running with. Larger, older enterprises tend not to have broadly distributed up-to-date DevOps skills across the whole organisation, and many also (or maybe as a result) have “trust” issues with giving teams the ability to customise and configure the hell out of everything.
I’ve even seen organisations build container platforms for their dev teams to use and then lock them down so much that they might as well have just used something like Cloud Run.
When should I use Autopilot?
Whenever you think “I should just use GKE” that’s when you should use Autopilot. UNLESS you have a really compelling reason (I bet you don’t. Seriously, whatever you’re thinking of right now is NOT a compelling reason. Except if it is).
When should I use GKE?
If you like things that are harder to setup, harder to manage and harder to maintain, then GKE is for you. Just kidding (not really), you should use GKE if you’re already using it and have already done the hard work of configuring it and learning all the nuances (and are blissfully unaware of the sunk cost fallacy).
But seriously, go ahead with GKE if you need fine-grained control of your cluster nodes (how many of them, what CPU & memory they’ll need etc) or if you have some super-specific security requirements that I can’t even think of (apart from Binary Auth as mentioned above).
You could use all of them. Why not? Use Cloud Run for the simpler stuff and Autopilot/GKE for the more complex (and edge cases).